Over the past decade, Teaching Excellence has risen right up the agenda of universities around the world. It’s worth pausing a moment to consider, and reflect on, from whence this concern began. Dating back to the 1990s, nations around the globe had either established or were in the process of establishing quality assurance frameworks which outlined baseline standards for education. Such frameworks were used to audit universities' educational offer, and external requirements to address accountability, value for money, and support for students’ credit transferability.
Concurrently, differentiation of an institution’s educational offer had become increasingly important, resulting from the marketisation of higher education and greater international mobility. Subsequently, the term ‘quality enhancement’ - further to the range of ‘value adds’ that institutions adopted to help both differentiate their offer, demonstrating the added benefits students gained from studying at their institutions. Thus began the global quest for ’teaching excellence’.
The UK has had a long history of investment in developing teaching excellence, summarised in the timeline below, which some readers will be familiar with. For the purposes of this commentary, the journey will begin in 2004.
The UK Higher Education Academy
In 2004, the Higher Education Academy (HEA) was launched, bringing together a range of disparate smaller organisations which, whilst focused on enhancing education, often duplicated the work of each other, not necessarily easy to navigate, and did not deliver holistic strategic impact. Put simply, the vision, of the HEA was to professionalise higher education teaching, working with higher education institutions alongside a range of stakeholders (including governments of the four nations of the UK). Through its work, best practices in quality enhancement were showcased, and the quest to define ’teaching excellence’ began.
In 2016, in anticipation of England’s introduction of a teaching excellence framework, a sub-set of the HEA’S Pro-vice-chancellor (PVC) network met to consider what a teaching excellence framework might comprise, with all agreeing a strategic approach with a clear plan of action were key components. The framework they put forward three main domains, later incorporated in the GTEA framework, summarised below.
Norway’s Centres for Excellence Initiative
In 2017, I was invited to discuss the evolution of Norway’s Centres for Excellence (CfE) initiative, which took some of its inspiration from the work undertaken in the UK, whilst recognising that the major shortcoming of the UK’s approach in their Centres for Excellence initiative was a failure to coordinate at the national level, or undertake rigorous monitoring and evaluation of impact of the whole scheme thereby to determining which initiatives produced the greatest positive impact. Further to the CfE Steering Group’s discussion, a framework was determined. This framework, taking a very strategic approach, reflected that teaching evaluation is a process of enhancement, is not risk-averse, and is supported by institutional culture and context. Chairing two rounds of this initiative led to my feeding back ideas into UK discussions; particularly to England’s development of its own Teaching Excellence Framework.
HEA involvement in developing the English Teaching Excellence Framework and subsequently the Global Teaching Excellence Framework
In developing the English framework, a wide-ranging group of expert stakeholders were assembled to influence the overall shape and constituent parts. The Higher Education Academy (HEA) had worked closely with its PVC network who were concerned to include a strong vision and strategic focus, and audit how this strategy was subsequently delivered (and to what effect), and an action plan further to the evaluation of areas of strength and areas where clearly more work needed to be done – determining that ‘Teaching Excellence’ was a journey, not an absolute. To capture all the work that had gone into the PVC s determination of an agreed Teaching Excellence Framework, it was decided to use their model to underpin a new, global teaching award, to be run in conjunction with Times Higher Education - the Global Teaching Excellence Award. This framework - slightly changed for the purposes of a global audience, comprised of the domains in Table 1.
After each of the three rounds of the GTEA, an independent evaluation was conducted. Key findings from these evaluations centred around firstly, what had worked well: a clear demonstration of a strategic direction for teaching and learning; and a demonstrable commitment to providing students with a well-rounded learning experience and support. And secondly, what not so well: lack of explicit evidence and too many segmented initiatives. By and large, all the universities participating from around the globe agreed that the process of auditing and undertaking a self-evaluation of their educational offer and impact had been worthwhile, as had, indeed, determining a set of actions to take their university forward to better meet the needs of their students.
E-Note
The E-note Erasmus Project (European Network on Teaching Excellence), was a three-year project which has recently ended, compiled case studies of teaching excellence initiatives across Europe, and gathered exemplars of best practice in training for lecturers both at the undergraduate and post-graduate level. Further to its summary findings and workshop event in June 2023, the conclusions made it clear that a pan-university European approach to promoting teaching excellence had been welcomed by participants, with recommendations stating that this coordination could be even stronger.
Reflections on the England's TEF 2023 exercise
An Office for Students (OFS) publication, undertaken by Professor Dilly Fung published an independent analysis of the most recent English TEF exercise, discussing the approaches to strategic improvements made in the submissions of 31 providers (out of 228) whose TEF ratings had improved this cycle. The two main areas highlighted were 1) how providers planned for and implemented their strategy and vision, and 2) evidenced and evaluated their successes. Furthermore, the report highlighted the importance of a range of partnerships. These may be with students, industry-related or civic. The best providers described the use of an operational framework to drive strategic change relating to teaching, curriculum design and student experience. Using these approaches, most of the 31 providers made explicit links between their strategic plan and vision, the actions taken, and subsequence impact and evaluation of improvements. The use of university-wide framework also allowed for consistent and coherent delivery. Undoubtedly, there will be much more discussion around what we can learn from these ‘most improved’ to ensure that we continue our quest for Teaching Excellence.
Final reflections of Teaching Excellence
Further to the robust work undertaken in evaluating both England’s TEF exercise and Norway’s CfE exercise - would it not be good to compare these examples of ‘teaching excellence’ with the rest of the world? And pull in the project findings of E-Note? Is it now time to move the myriad exemplary case studies beyond the confines of the nations mentioned above, and take a more global perspective, once again, on Teaching Excellence? Which begs the question, is now the time for a new, super-charged GTEA to be resurrected? And, if so, by whom? I leave that one with you!
Financing Syria's Recovery: The EU and a Fragile Economic Opening
financing-syrias-recovery-the-eu-and-a-fragile-economic-opening
Briefing
Global Economy
August 12, 2026
European Defence: The European Union Framework as a Dead End
european-defence-the-european-union-framework-as-a-dead-end
Briefing
Peace and Security
July 22, 2026
The New Development Bank Joins the Shift Towards Nuclear Energy Financing
the-new-development-bank-joins-the-shift-towards-nuclear-energy-financing
Commentary
Global Economy
July 13, 2026
.png)
An Issue Area Approach to Defending Global Governance
an-issue-area-approach-to-defending-global-governance
Briefing
Peace and Security
July 2, 2026
Europe’s Defence Supply Chains Need Africa and the Global South
europes-defence-supply-chains-need-africa-and-the-global-south
Commentary
Global Economy
June 12, 2026
Retrenchment as Policy Failure: Aid Cuts, the Post-UNITAMS Vacuum, and Sudan's Civilian Crisis
retrenchment-as-policy-failure-aid-cuts-the-post-unitams-vacuum-and-sudans-civilian-crisis
Briefing
Peace and Security
May 28, 2026
The Illusion of AI Sovereignty: Mapping the Five-Layer AI Stack
the-illusion-of-ai-sovereignty-mapping-the-five-layer-ai-stack
Commentary
AI Governance
May 15, 2026
Towards a Science for Diplomacy? The U7+ Alliance and the Strategic Repositioning of Universities in Global Governance
towards-a-science-for-diplomacy-the-u-7-alliance-and-the-strategic-repositioning-of-universities-in-global-governance
Commentary
Global Education
April 27, 2026
The Capability Overhang: Cognition and Labor in the Age of AI
the-capability-overhang-cognition-and-labor-in-the-age-of-ai
Commentary
AI Governance
April 9, 2026
.png)
The UN80 Initiative as a Productive Failure: Between Geopolitical Disruptions and Organizational Path Dependency
the-un80-initiative-as-a-productive-failure-between-geopolitical-disruptions-and-organizational-path-dependency
Analysis
Peace and Security
March 31, 2026
Higher Education at a Crossroads: Why Europe’s Universities Must Lead, Not Merely Comply
higher-education-at-a-crossroads-why-europes-universities-must-lead-not-merely-comply
Commentary
Global Education
February 23, 2026
What Comes After the US-Israel Strikes on the Islamic Republic?
what-comes-after-the-us-israel-strikes-on-the-islamic-republic
Commentary
Peace and Security
December 19, 2025
Do You Know What’s in Your Skies? Emerging Challenges for Civil Aviation Governance
do-you-know-whats-in-your-skies-emerging-challenges-for-civil-aviation-governance
Commentary
AI Governance
December 18, 2025
Knowledge creation in times of scarce resources in higher education
knowledge-creation-in-times-of-scarce-resources-in-higher-education
Commentary
Global Education
November 10, 2025
Justice-Ready Digital Public Infrastructure: Building a Third Layer of Trust for Democratic Resilience
justice-ready-digital-public-infrastructure-building-a-third-layer-of-trust-for-democratic-resilience
Briefing
AI Governance
October 23, 2025
Is a Greener Future for AI Possible?
is-a-greener-future-for-ai-possible
Commentary
AI Governance
October 20, 2025
Silencing Dissent: How the Tech Backlash Threatens Transitional Justice
silencing-dissent-how-the-tech-backlash-threatens-transitional-justice
Commentary
AI Governance
October 2, 2025
Holding NATO Together and Keeping the US Engaged: Strategic Implications of the Hague Summit
holding-nato-together-and-keeping-the-us-engaged-strategic-implications-of-the-hague-summit
Analysis
Peace and Security
September 9, 2025
Reforming the UN during a financial crisis: a foreseeable failure to align money, mandates, and majorities?
reforming-the-un-during-a-financial-crisis-a-foreseeable-failure-to-align-money-mandates-and-majorities
Briefing
Peace and Security
July 9, 2025
How do we measure the quality of education?
how-do-we-measure-the-quality-of-education
Commentary
Global Education
April 28, 2025
Bound to Fail? The Limits of Diplomacy in the Russia–Ukraine War and the Future of European Security
bound-to-fail-the-limits-of-diplomacy-in-the-russia-ukraine-war-and-the-future-of-european-security
Commentary
Peace and Security
April 8, 2025
A major shift in global higher education is underway: why collective leadership and governance are more important than ever
a-major-shift-in-global-higher-education-is-underway-why-collective-leadership-and-governance-are-more-important-than-ever
Commentary
Global Education
March 26, 2025
AI's Fast-Forward Button: Can We Harness Innovation Without Sacrificing Safety?
ais-fast-forward-button-can-we-harness-innovation-without-sacrificing-safety
Commentary
AI Governance
March 10, 2025
Parliaments in the EU enlargement process: Strengthening capacities of accession country parliaments under the evolving enlargement methodology
parliaments-in-the-eu-enlargement-process-strengthening-capacities-of-accession-country-parliaments-under-the-evolving-enlargement-methodology
Report
Democracy and Human Rights
January 30, 2025
%20(1200%20x%20600%20px)%20(1200%20x%20400%20px).png)
Synthetic Biology and the Future of Global Environmental Governance
synthetic-biology-and-the-future-of-global-environmental-governance
Analysis
Global Environmental Governance
January 28, 2025
Towards a Global Agency for Governing Artificial General Intelligence: Challenges and Perspectives
towards-a-global-agency-for-governing-artificial-general-intelligence-challenges-and-perspectives
Report
AI Governance
January 14, 2025
Normalizing Russia can become Trump’s biggest mistake, but it’s not too late to prevent it
normalizing-russia-can-become-trumps-biggest-mistake-but-its-not-too-late-to-prevent-it
Commentary
Peace and Security
January 13, 2025
Stabilizing Europe’s Security Architecture after the Russo-Ukraine War? The Future of Conventional Arms Control in Europe
stabilizing-europes-security-architecture-after-the-russo-ukraine-war-the-future-of-conventional-arms-control-in-europe
Briefing
Peace and Security
November 20, 2024
INTERPOL: Challenges and Opportunities for the New Secretary General
interpol-challenges-and-opportunities-for-the-new-secretary-general
Commentary
Peace and Security
November 7, 2024
A Fork in the Road? The Kazan Summit of the BRICS
a-fork-in-the-road-the-kazan-summit-of-the-brics
Briefing
Peace and Security
October 30, 2024
UN Summit of the Future and Development: The Way Forward
un-summit-of-the-future-and-development-the-way-forward
Briefing
AI Governance
October 24, 2024
ECOWAS after the ‘Triple Withdrawal’ and the creation of the Alliance of Sahel States
ecowas-after-the-triple-withdrawal-and-the-creation-of-the-alliance-of-sahel-states-challenges-and-ways-ahead-for-regional-security-governance
Analysis
Peace and Security
October 7, 2024
Rushing to Peace, Racing to War: The Challenge of a Just Settlement
rushing-to-peace-racing-to-war-the-challenge-of-a-just-settlement
Commentary
Peace and Security
September 30, 2024
UN Summit of the Future: A Critical Moment for Global AI Governance
un-summit-of-the-future-a-critical-moment-for-global-ai-governance
Commentary
AI Governance
September 20, 2024
Shattered Security: Gender And Coups In Guinea, Mali, And Burkina Faso
shattered-security-gender-and-coups-in-guinea-mali-and-burkina-faso
Briefing
Peace and Security
June 26, 2024
Before the Peace Summit: Testing Multilateralism and Ukrainian Diplomacy
before-the-peace-summit-testing-multilateralism-and-ukrainian-diplomacy
Commentary
Peace and Security
June 14, 2024
The On-Going Quest for Teaching Excellence
the-on-going-quest-for-teaching-excellence
Commentary
Global Education
June 11, 2024
Deepening EU-Japan-US Cooperation on Critical and Emerging Technologies
deepening-eu-japan-us-cooperation-on-critical-and-emerging-technologies
Commentary
AI Governance
May 7, 2024
UNRWA’s Funding Freeze was Unjustified and Undermined Good Governance
unrwas-funding-freeze-was-unjustified-and-undermined-good-governance
Briefing
Democracy and Human Rights
April 25, 2024
Israel’s Non-implementation of the ICJ’s Provisional Measures: International Law Must Be Upheld
israels-non-implementation-of-the-icjs-provisional-measures-international-law-must-be-upheld
Briefing
Democracy and Human Rights
April 2, 2024
The EU AI Act: two steps forward, one step back
the-eu-ai-act-two-steps-forward-one-step-back
Briefing
AI Governance
March 19, 2024
The Council of Europe’s draft AI Treaty: balancing national security, innovation and human rights?
the-council-of-europes-draft-ai-treaty-balancing-national-security-innovation-and-human-rights
Commentary
AI Governance
March 18, 2024
The Ukrainian Peace Formula: content, evolution and diplomatic outreach
the-ukrainian-peace-formula-content-evolution-and-diplomatic-outreach
Analysis
Peace and Security
February 26, 2024
What developments in AI tell us about the future of governance models
what-developments-in-ai-tell-us-about-the-future-of-governance-models
Commentary
AI Governance
February 21, 2024
Whither the Global Governance of Protecting Civilians? An Initial Assessment of the ICJ’s Decision on South Africa v. Israel of 26 January 2024
whither-the-global-governance-of-protecting-civilians-an-initial-assessment-of-the-icjs-decision-on-south-africa-v-israel-of-26-january-2024
Analysis
Democracy and Human Rights
February 14, 2024
How Ukraine uses AI to fight Russian information operations
how-ukraine-uses-ai-to-fight-russian-information-operations
Commentary
AI Governance
February 12, 2024
Got trust? Global governance of emerging technologies
got-trust-global-governance-of-emerging-technologies
Commentary
AI Governance
November 28, 2023
Last minute national objections to the EU’s AI Act are a mistake. Here’s why
rolling-back-the-ai-act-is-a-mistake-heres-why
Commentary
AI Governance
November 27, 2023
Contributions of Latin America and the Caribbean to UN Peace Operations and Recommendations to Increase this Participation
new-ggi-advice-report-latin-american-and-caribbean-countries-contributions-to-un-peacekeeping
Report
Peace and Security
October 12, 2023
Armed Conflict in Nagorno-Karabakh: Crisis, Exodus, and Ethnic Cleansing
armed-conflict-in-nagorno-karabakh-crisis-exodus-and-ethnic-cleansing
Briefing
Peace and Security
October 9, 2023
Thinking of Eloho – One Year On
thinking-of-eloho-one-year-on
Commentary
Peace and Security
August 12, 2023
The Strategic Compass and the EU's Security & Defence Partnerships
the-strategic-compass-implementing-the-partnership-dimension-in-the-area-of-security-and-defence
Report
Peace and Security
July 23, 2023
Franco-German Perspectives: Europe's Moment of Geopolitics
franco-german-perspectives-europes-moment-of-geopolitics
Commentary
Peace and Security
June 2, 2023
A Comprehensive Mapping of National Higher Education Teaching Qualification schemes, Requirements and Provisions for the Promotion and Reward of Teaching Excellence
a-comprehensive-mapping-of-national-higher-education-teaching-qualification-schemes-requirements-and-provisions-for-the-promotion-and-reward-of-teaching-excellence
Report
Global Education
June 1, 2023
Stefaan de Rynck 'Inside the deal: How the EU got Brexit Done'
stefaan-de-ryncks-inside-the-deal-how-the-eu-got-brexit-done
Commentary
Global Education
April 5, 2023
NATO Allies and the Protection of Civilians
nato-allies-and-the-protection-of-civilians
Analysis
Peace and Security
January 11, 2023
Why Jettison Erasmus? The negative consequences for the UK of walking away
why-jettison-erasmus
Commentary
Global Education
January 1, 2021
Doing less with more? The difficult return of Western troop contributing countries to UN Peacekeeping
doing-less-with-more
Analysis
Peace and Security
November 2, 2020
The European Union's Role in International Economic Fora – Paper 4: The IMF
the-european-unions-role-in-international-economic-fora-paper-4-the-imf
Report
Global Economy
September 1, 2015
Civil Society Reforms in Uzbekistan: More than Government Chicanery?
civil-society-reforms-in-uzbekistan-more-than-government-chicanery
Briefing
Peace and Security
January 1, 2014
Assessing the EU’s Joint Communication on the Comprehensive Approach: Implications for EU Crisis Response and Conflict Prevention
assessing-the-eus-joint-communication-on-the-comprehensive-approach
Briefing
Peace and Security
December 15, 2013
The EU Foreign Policy of My Dreams: Ten Wishes
the-eu-foreign-policy-of-my-dreams-ten-wishes
Views from Practice
Peace and Security
December 12, 2013
The Middle East as weapons of mass destruction free zone: A proposal to overcome the deadlock
the-middle-east-as-weapons-of-mass-destruction-free-zone-a-proposal-to-overcome-the-deadlock
Views from Practice
Peace and Security
October 15, 2013
From a Militarized to a Humanized Responsibility to Protect
from-a-militarized-to-a-humanized-responsibility-to-protect-integrating-the-red-cross-and-red-crescent-into-rtop-to-respond-to-natural-disasters-and-global-climate-change
Analysis
Global Environmental Governance
June 1, 2013
Leading the Peacebuilding Commission: An Institutional History in the Making
leading-the-peacebuilding-commission-an-institutional-history-in-the-making
Views from Practice
Peace and Security
March 1, 2013
Anticipating the “Final” Arms Trade Treaty Conference: Eight Concrete Proposals
anticipating-the-final-arms-trade-treaty-conference-eight-concrete-proposals
Analysis
Peace and Security
February 1, 2013
Report for the Inquiry into the European External Action Service – EU sub-committee on External Affairs of the House Of Lords
report-for-the-inquiry-into-the-european-external-action-service---eu-sub-committee-on-external-affairs-of-the-house-of-lords
Briefing
Peace and Security
December 1, 2012
Government and the Process of Governance in Africa
government-and-the-process-of-governance-in-africa
Analysis
Peace and Security
November 1, 2012
The Responsibility to Protect and the Responsibility while Protecting: Friends or Foes?
the-responsibility-to-protect-and-the-responsibility-while-protecting-friends-or-foes
Analysis
Democracy and Human Rights
September 15, 2012
Montenegro’s Accession To The EU: Taking Stock And Suggesting Areas For Progress
montenegros-accession-to-the-eu-taking-stock-and-suggesting-areas-for-progress
Briefing
Democracy and Human Rights
August 1, 2012
Electing Freedom? Key Challenges For Libya After The 7 July 2012 Election
electing-freedom-key-challenges-for-libya-after-the-7-july-2012-election
Briefing
Peace and Security
August 1, 2012
The Somali Crisis and the EU: Moving Onshore and Committing to Somalia
the-somali-crisis-and-the-eu-moving-onshore-and-committing-to-somalia
Analysis
Peace and Security
July 1, 2012
United Nations - European Union Cooperation in the Field of Peacekeeping: Challenges and Prospects
united-nations-european-union-cooperation-in-the-field-of-peacekeeping-challenges-and-prospects
Analysis
Peace and Security
June 1, 2012
Widening The Huntress’s Reach: Legal And Strategic Aspects Of A New Atalanta Mandate
legal-and-strategic-aspects-of-a-new-atalanta-mandate
Briefing
Democracy and Human Rights
April 15, 2012
The Biological Weapons Convention, Bioterrorism And The Life Sciences
the-biological-weapons-convention-bioterrorism-and-the-life-sciences
Briefing
Peace and Security
April 1, 2012
A Democratic Justification for Military and Non-military Humanitarian Intervention
a-democratic-justification-for-military-and-non-military-humanitarian-interventions
Analysis
Democracy and Human Rights
April 1, 2012
Climate Change and Security: Adapting the Discussion to the Evidence
climate-change-and-security
Briefing
Global Environmental Governance
March 15, 2012
The United Nations Entity for Gender Equality and the Empowerment of Women (UN Women)
the-united-nations-entity-for-gender-equality-and-the-empowerment-of-women-un-women
Backgrounder
Peace and Security
September 1, 2011
The International Criminal Court and Kenya’s Post-election Violence
the-international-criminal-court-and-kenyas-post-election-violence
Analysis
Democracy and Human Rights
July 15, 2011
The United Nations Peacebuilding Architecture: Background Note
the-united-nations-peacebuilding-architecture-background-note
Briefing
Peace and Security
March 1, 2011
European Civilian Crisis Management Capacities: Bridging The Resources Gap?
european-civilian-crisis-management-capacities-bridging-the-resources-gap
Briefing
Peace and Security
January 15, 2011
The Changing Constellation of Power and Resistance in the Global Debate over Agrofuels
the-changing-constellation-of-power-and-resistance-in-the-global-debate-over-agrofuels
Analysis
Global Environmental Governance
January 1, 2011
