What developments in AI tell us about the future of governance models

Medlir Mema
Commentary
AI Governance
Published
21
February 2024
7
minute read

Misinformation and disinformation have become this year’s buzzwords as voters in over 40 countries head to the voting booths in 2024 along with dozens more scheduled to be held in 2025. Not everyone shares the concern or the outlook, but there is no doubt that the next two years will be decisive for the future of democracy and societies around the world.

In the meantime, artificial intelligence (AI) promises to exponentially increase the availability and production of information in all of its forms, while also rendering our interface with it more difficult. Just as it was aided in the past by revolutionary technological advances—printing press, telegraph, telephone, computers, internet—it seems that the production, collection, and dissemination of information sits on the cusp of a possibly unprecedented leap forward.

Paradoxically, perhaps, as the nature and amount of information increases in complexity and size, the delivery mechanisms, whether text, audio, or video-based, for such information continues to shrink in direct proportion to decreasing attention spans and the ever-narrowing echo-chambers of its users. If “the medium is the message,” as Marshall McCluhan was keen to point out, then one wonders what the message is. These of course are not new problems, but the democratisation of information, the proliferation of new AI-super charged media of production and delivery, and the erosion of trust across a variety of institutions and social norms, make for an explosive combination.

Instead of producing better informed and more discerning citizens, mass hysteria, groupthink, the embrace of wide-spread conspiracy theories, atavistic ideologies, as well as enforced conformity, often follow. It turns out, however, that when dealing with crowd dynamics, a thin line separates Douglas Murray’s madness of the crowds–how groupthink and mob mentality override reason, leading to irrational behaviour and collective hysteria–, from James Surowiecki’s wisdom of the crowd–how diverse groups of people can collectively make better decisions than individual experts.

Otherwise referred to as collective, swarm, or hive intelligence, the wisdom of the crowd argument relies on the observed collective problem-solving ability or decision-making capacity of a group, where each individual contributes their own knowledge, perspectives, and experiences to arrive at a solution or decision. This concept is often observed in social insects like bees or ants, where the collective behaviour of the group leads to complex, coordinated actions.

AI can help enhance hive intelligence in several ways. Firstly, AI algorithms can analyse vast amounts of data contributed by individuals within the group to identify patterns, trends, and correlations that might not be immediately apparent to humans. AI can also facilitate communication and collaboration among group members by providing platforms for sharing information, coordinating efforts, and synthesising diverse viewpoints. Finally, AI-powered prediction models and decision-making tools can assist the group in evaluating different options and selecting the most optimal course of action based on the collective input. As a result, overall, AI technologies have the potential to augment and amplify the collective intelligence of groups, enabling more effective problem-solving and decision-making processes.

Swarm-based predictive models built by UnanimousAI or HivePoweredAi, for example, have contributed in a variety of fields including medicine, UN decision-making, business resource allocation, marketing, and even voting. Commenting on the benefits of tapping into AI-enabled collective intelligence models, Louis Rosenberg, Unanimous AI’s CEO and Chief Scientist, noted that the shifting away from traditional polling methods that drive voter polarisation further, “the biological principle of swarm intelligence can point us in the right direction, enabling us to make group decisions, big and small, that more accurately reflect our collective insights and aspirations.”

These examples serve as important reminders of the reason why cooperative networks and varied governance models were created in the first place. It turns out that while misinformation and disinformation, and therefore distrust thrive in an atomised, polarised, and isolated society, the opposite is true in a society that ‘comes together.’ The consequences of the former, it turns out, are dire, for both institutions and individuals.

This insight is important, not least because over the past decade or so, trust has eroded at alarming rates. Increased access to internet connectivity and the democratisation of information from the 1990s onward, meant that traditional sources of authority were found wanting: too slow, too old, too opaque, too unaccountable, too vertical. Universities, government offices, international organisations, media outlets, religious organisations, once considered the only legitimate sources of status and power, were increasingly forced to loosen their grip once their monopoly over knowledge and information, the only source of their legitimacy, was no longer secure.

The end result, has been the creation of overlapping and yet fragmented layers of ‘reality’, where each individual and or members of a group live their own ‘truth’, apart from that of others, with each of them empowered by instantaneous access to an almost infinite supply of information, both trivial and profound, long-lasting and ephemeral. Due to this erosion of trust in traditional sources of authority, under the best circumstances, this fragmentation into various and competing versions of realities has resulted in societal alienation and polarisation.

However, we may no longer be able to continue operating under a ‘best circumstances’ scenario. Whereas, it is true that in the past, a myriad of idiosyncratic and social factors, including one’s cognitive biases or tribal affinities, be they political, economic, or social based, stopped one from properly interpreting the information available to them, in the overwhelming number of cases, there was never any doubt as to their provenance.

That may no longer be the case. AI-generated content, both dependent and independent of human promptings, will likely exceed human created ones in the coming years. While many have expressed optimism that current limitations and failings of large language models like ChatGPT or Bard will likely be overcome or at least minimised in the future, some are less sanguine. Recent reports, for example, show that not only is ChatGPT performance plateauing, it may actually be getting worse. Evidence that these models suffer from hallucinations, fabrications, and even laziness, continue to pile up.

The end result is the production, dissemination, and consumption of facts, news, analyses, etc that are defective by default. And that’s before we consider the concerns and the pathologies resulting from algorithmic and set up biases, the first the result of incomplete and biased data and erroneous design, the latter, the outcome of biased individuals making decisions leading to pathological outcomes.

Then there is the intentional and malicious use of technology to sow misinformation and disinformation. The seriousness of the threat is underlined by the fact that the United States, the European Union, and the NATO, have made combating Foreign Induced Misinformation (FIMI) one of their top priorities for 2024-2025. Moreover, during the 2024 Munich Security Conference, some of the world’s largest social media and AI platforms signed a voluntary pledge to tamper or outright stop the proliferation of some AI-produced election-related materials.

However, the problem with AI-curated and disseminated misinformation and disinformation goes beyond concerns with elections and is likely to become one of the greatest challenges looking ahead, one that is made even more difficult due to the onslaught on traditional sources of trust. Interestingly, this may create an opportunity for old and new institutions. As some have already suggested, whereas the democratisation of information in the 1990s favoured the sidestepping of institutions, the proliferation of AI-induced and enabled misinformation and disinformation may provide a way back for them as it becomes increasingly difficult to distinguish fact from fiction, reality from science fiction.

The ‘comeback’ of traditional institutional frameworks and trust is not a foregone conclusion, however. New institutional forms of signalling trust may make it difficult for ‘old’ institutions to regain their footing. Despite the historic usefulness of some institutions as ‘trust signifiers’ giving their seal of approval to some information and withholding it from others, citizens may not find highly rigid and hierarchical forms of governance appealing. ‘Old’ institutions like universities, national governments, international organisations, regional bodies, etc, must then avoid becoming what people around the world have already rejected. To regain their legitimacy, they must first recognise that horizontality, transparency, and openness are three non-negotiable principles upon which every attempt to regain trust must be built.

AI Governance

A Blueprint for the Global Governance of Autonomous Weapon Systems

a-blueprint-for-the-global-governance-of-autonomous-weapon-systems

Report

Peace and Security

August 28, 2026

AI, Sustainable Development and the Future of Education: A Governance Imperative

ai-sustainable-development-and-the-future-of-education-a-governance-imperative

Commentary

Global Education

August 17, 2026

Financing Syria's Recovery: The EU and a Fragile Economic Opening

financing-syrias-recovery-the-eu-and-a-fragile-economic-opening

Briefing

Global Economy

August 12, 2026

European Defence: The European Union Framework as a Dead End

european-defence-the-european-union-framework-as-a-dead-end

Briefing

Peace and Security

July 22, 2026

The New Development Bank Joins the Shift Towards Nuclear Energy Financing

the-new-development-bank-joins-the-shift-towards-nuclear-energy-financing

Commentary

Global Economy

July 13, 2026

An Issue Area Approach to Defending Global Governance

an-issue-area-approach-to-defending-global-governance

Briefing

Peace and Security

July 2, 2026

Europe’s Defence Supply Chains Need Africa and the Global South

europes-defence-supply-chains-need-africa-and-the-global-south

Commentary

Global Economy

June 12, 2026

Retrenchment as Policy Failure: Aid Cuts, the Post-UNITAMS Vacuum, and Sudan's Civilian Crisis

retrenchment-as-policy-failure-aid-cuts-the-post-unitams-vacuum-and-sudans-civilian-crisis

Briefing

Peace and Security

May 28, 2026

The Illusion of AI Sovereignty: Mapping the Five-Layer AI Stack

the-illusion-of-ai-sovereignty-mapping-the-five-layer-ai-stack

Commentary

AI Governance

May 15, 2026

Towards a Science for Diplomacy? The U7+ Alliance and the Strategic Repositioning of Universities in Global Governance

towards-a-science-for-diplomacy-the-u-7-alliance-and-the-strategic-repositioning-of-universities-in-global-governance

Commentary

Global Education

April 27, 2026

The Capability Overhang: Cognition and Labor in the Age of AI

the-capability-overhang-cognition-and-labor-in-the-age-of-ai

Commentary

AI Governance

April 9, 2026

The UN80 Initiative as a Productive Failure: Between Geopolitical Disruptions and Organizational Path Dependency

the-un80-initiative-as-a-productive-failure-between-geopolitical-disruptions-and-organizational-path-dependency

Analysis

Peace and Security

March 31, 2026

Higher Education at a Crossroads: Why Europe’s Universities Must Lead, Not Merely Comply

higher-education-at-a-crossroads-why-europes-universities-must-lead-not-merely-comply

Commentary

Global Education

February 23, 2026

What Comes After the US-Israel Strikes on the Islamic Republic?

what-comes-after-the-us-israel-strikes-on-the-islamic-republic

Commentary

Peace and Security

December 19, 2025

Do You Know What’s in Your Skies? Emerging Challenges for Civil Aviation Governance

do-you-know-whats-in-your-skies-emerging-challenges-for-civil-aviation-governance

Commentary

AI Governance

December 18, 2025

Knowledge creation in times of scarce resources in higher education

knowledge-creation-in-times-of-scarce-resources-in-higher-education

Commentary

Global Education

November 10, 2025

Justice-Ready Digital Public Infrastructure: Building a Third Layer of Trust for Democratic Resilience

justice-ready-digital-public-infrastructure-building-a-third-layer-of-trust-for-democratic-resilience

Briefing

AI Governance

October 23, 2025

Is a Greener Future for AI Possible?

is-a-greener-future-for-ai-possible

Commentary

AI Governance

October 20, 2025

Silencing Dissent: How the Tech Backlash Threatens Transitional Justice

silencing-dissent-how-the-tech-backlash-threatens-transitional-justice

Commentary

AI Governance

October 2, 2025

Holding NATO Together and Keeping the US Engaged: Strategic Implications of the Hague Summit

holding-nato-together-and-keeping-the-us-engaged-strategic-implications-of-the-hague-summit

Analysis

Peace and Security

September 9, 2025

Reforming the UN during a financial crisis: a foreseeable failure to align money, mandates, and majorities?

reforming-the-un-during-a-financial-crisis-a-foreseeable-failure-to-align-money-mandates-and-majorities

Briefing

Peace and Security

July 9, 2025

How do we measure the quality of education?

how-do-we-measure-the-quality-of-education

Commentary

Global Education

April 28, 2025

Bound to Fail? The Limits of Diplomacy in the Russia–Ukraine War and the Future of European Security

bound-to-fail-the-limits-of-diplomacy-in-the-russia-ukraine-war-and-the-future-of-european-security

Commentary

Peace and Security

April 8, 2025

A major shift in global higher education is underway: why collective leadership and governance are more important than ever

a-major-shift-in-global-higher-education-is-underway-why-collective-leadership-and-governance-are-more-important-than-ever

Commentary

Global Education

March 26, 2025

AI's Fast-Forward Button: Can We Harness Innovation Without Sacrificing Safety?

ais-fast-forward-button-can-we-harness-innovation-without-sacrificing-safety

Commentary

AI Governance

March 10, 2025

Parliaments in the EU enlargement process: Strengthening capacities of accession country parliaments under the evolving enlargement methodology

parliaments-in-the-eu-enlargement-process-strengthening-capacities-of-accession-country-parliaments-under-the-evolving-enlargement-methodology

Report

Democracy and Human Rights

January 30, 2025

Synthetic Biology and the Future of Global Environmental Governance

synthetic-biology-and-the-future-of-global-environmental-governance

Analysis

Global Environmental Governance

January 28, 2025

Towards a Global Agency for Governing Artificial General Intelligence: Challenges and Perspectives

towards-a-global-agency-for-governing-artificial-general-intelligence-challenges-and-perspectives

Report

AI Governance

January 14, 2025

Normalizing Russia can become Trump’s biggest mistake, but it’s not too late to prevent it

normalizing-russia-can-become-trumps-biggest-mistake-but-its-not-too-late-to-prevent-it

Commentary

Peace and Security

January 13, 2025

Stabilizing Europe’s Security Architecture after the Russo-Ukraine War? The Future of Conventional Arms Control in Europe

stabilizing-europes-security-architecture-after-the-russo-ukraine-war-the-future-of-conventional-arms-control-in-europe

Briefing

Peace and Security

November 20, 2024

INTERPOL: Challenges and Opportunities for the New Secretary General

interpol-challenges-and-opportunities-for-the-new-secretary-general

Commentary

Peace and Security

November 7, 2024

A Fork in the Road? The Kazan Summit of the BRICS

a-fork-in-the-road-the-kazan-summit-of-the-brics

Briefing

Peace and Security

October 30, 2024

UN Summit of the Future and Development: The Way Forward

un-summit-of-the-future-and-development-the-way-forward

Briefing

AI Governance

October 24, 2024

ECOWAS after the ‘Triple Withdrawal’ and the creation of the Alliance of Sahel States

ecowas-after-the-triple-withdrawal-and-the-creation-of-the-alliance-of-sahel-states-challenges-and-ways-ahead-for-regional-security-governance

Analysis

Peace and Security

October 7, 2024

Rushing to Peace, Racing to War: The Challenge of a Just Settlement

rushing-to-peace-racing-to-war-the-challenge-of-a-just-settlement

Commentary

Peace and Security

September 30, 2024

UN Summit of the Future: A Critical Moment for Global AI Governance

un-summit-of-the-future-a-critical-moment-for-global-ai-governance

Commentary

AI Governance

September 20, 2024

Shattered Security: Gender And Coups In Guinea, Mali, And Burkina Faso

shattered-security-gender-and-coups-in-guinea-mali-and-burkina-faso

Briefing

Peace and Security

June 26, 2024

Before the Peace Summit: Testing Multilateralism and Ukrainian Diplomacy

before-the-peace-summit-testing-multilateralism-and-ukrainian-diplomacy

Commentary

Peace and Security

June 14, 2024

The On-Going Quest for Teaching Excellence

the-on-going-quest-for-teaching-excellence

Commentary

Global Education

June 11, 2024

Deepening EU-Japan-US Cooperation on Critical and Emerging Technologies

deepening-eu-japan-us-cooperation-on-critical-and-emerging-technologies

Commentary

AI Governance

May 7, 2024

UNRWA’s Funding Freeze was Unjustified and Undermined Good Governance

unrwas-funding-freeze-was-unjustified-and-undermined-good-governance

Briefing

Democracy and Human Rights

April 25, 2024

Israel’s Non-implementation of the ICJ’s Provisional Measures: International Law Must Be Upheld

israels-non-implementation-of-the-icjs-provisional-measures-international-law-must-be-upheld

Briefing

Democracy and Human Rights

April 2, 2024

The EU AI Act: two steps forward, one step back

the-eu-ai-act-two-steps-forward-one-step-back

Briefing

AI Governance

March 19, 2024

The Council of Europe’s draft AI Treaty: balancing national security, innovation and human rights?

the-council-of-europes-draft-ai-treaty-balancing-national-security-innovation-and-human-rights

Commentary

AI Governance

March 18, 2024

The Ukrainian Peace Formula: content, evolution and diplomatic outreach

the-ukrainian-peace-formula-content-evolution-and-diplomatic-outreach

Analysis

Peace and Security

February 26, 2024

What developments in AI tell us about the future of governance models

what-developments-in-ai-tell-us-about-the-future-of-governance-models

Commentary

AI Governance

February 21, 2024

Whither the Global Governance of Protecting Civilians? An Initial Assessment of the ICJ’s Decision on South Africa v. Israel of 26 January 2024

whither-the-global-governance-of-protecting-civilians-an-initial-assessment-of-the-icjs-decision-on-south-africa-v-israel-of-26-january-2024

Analysis

Democracy and Human Rights

February 14, 2024

How Ukraine uses AI to fight Russian information operations

how-ukraine-uses-ai-to-fight-russian-information-operations

Commentary

AI Governance

February 12, 2024

Got trust? Global governance of emerging technologies

got-trust-global-governance-of-emerging-technologies

Commentary

AI Governance

November 28, 2023

Last minute national objections to the EU’s AI Act are a mistake. Here’s why

rolling-back-the-ai-act-is-a-mistake-heres-why

Commentary

AI Governance

November 27, 2023

Contributions of Latin America and the Caribbean to UN Peace Operations and Recommendations to Increase this Participation

new-ggi-advice-report-latin-american-and-caribbean-countries-contributions-to-un-peacekeeping

Report

Peace and Security

October 12, 2023

Armed Conflict in Nagorno-Karabakh: Crisis, Exodus, and Ethnic Cleansing

armed-conflict-in-nagorno-karabakh-crisis-exodus-and-ethnic-cleansing

Briefing

Peace and Security

October 9, 2023

Thinking of Eloho – One Year On

thinking-of-eloho-one-year-on

Commentary

Peace and Security

August 12, 2023

The Strategic Compass and the EU's Security & Defence Partnerships

the-strategic-compass-implementing-the-partnership-dimension-in-the-area-of-security-and-defence

Report

Peace and Security

July 23, 2023

Franco-German Perspectives: Europe's Moment of Geopolitics

franco-german-perspectives-europes-moment-of-geopolitics

Commentary

Peace and Security

June 2, 2023

A Comprehensive Mapping of National Higher Education Teaching Qualification schemes, Requirements and Provisions for the Promotion and Reward of Teaching Excellence

a-comprehensive-mapping-of-national-higher-education-teaching-qualification-schemes-requirements-and-provisions-for-the-promotion-and-reward-of-teaching-excellence

Report

Global Education

June 1, 2023

Stefaan de Rynck 'Inside the deal: How the EU got Brexit Done'

stefaan-de-ryncks-inside-the-deal-how-the-eu-got-brexit-done

Commentary

Global Education

April 5, 2023

NATO Allies and the Protection of Civilians

nato-allies-and-the-protection-of-civilians

Analysis

Peace and Security

January 11, 2023

Why Jettison Erasmus? The negative consequences for the UK of walking away

why-jettison-erasmus

Commentary

Global Education

January 1, 2021

Doing less with more? The difficult return of Western troop contributing countries to UN Peacekeeping

doing-less-with-more

Analysis

Peace and Security

November 2, 2020

The European Union's Role in International Economic Fora – Paper 4: The IMF

the-european-unions-role-in-international-economic-fora-paper-4-the-imf

Report

Global Economy

September 1, 2015

Civil Society Reforms in Uzbekistan: More than Government Chicanery?

civil-society-reforms-in-uzbekistan-more-than-government-chicanery

Briefing

Peace and Security

January 1, 2014

Assessing the EU’s Joint Communication on the Comprehensive Approach: Implications for EU Crisis Response and Conflict Prevention

assessing-the-eus-joint-communication-on-the-comprehensive-approach

Briefing

Peace and Security

December 15, 2013

The EU Foreign Policy of My Dreams: Ten Wishes

the-eu-foreign-policy-of-my-dreams-ten-wishes

Views from Practice

Peace and Security

December 12, 2013

The Middle East as weapons of mass destruction free zone: A proposal to overcome the deadlock

the-middle-east-as-weapons-of-mass-destruction-free-zone-a-proposal-to-overcome-the-deadlock

Views from Practice

Peace and Security

October 15, 2013

From a Militarized to a Humanized Responsibility to Protect

from-a-militarized-to-a-humanized-responsibility-to-protect-integrating-the-red-cross-and-red-crescent-into-rtop-to-respond-to-natural-disasters-and-global-climate-change

Analysis

Global Environmental Governance

June 1, 2013

Leading the Peacebuilding Commission: An Institutional History in the Making

leading-the-peacebuilding-commission-an-institutional-history-in-the-making

Views from Practice

Peace and Security

March 1, 2013

Anticipating the “Final” Arms Trade Treaty Conference: Eight Concrete Proposals

anticipating-the-final-arms-trade-treaty-conference-eight-concrete-proposals

Analysis

Peace and Security

February 1, 2013

Report for the Inquiry into the European External Action Service – EU sub-committee on External Affairs of the House Of Lords

report-for-the-inquiry-into-the-european-external-action-service---eu-sub-committee-on-external-affairs-of-the-house-of-lords

Briefing

Peace and Security

December 1, 2012

Government and the Process of Governance in Africa

government-and-the-process-of-governance-in-africa

Analysis

Peace and Security

November 1, 2012

The Responsibility to Protect and the Responsibility while Protecting: Friends or Foes?

the-responsibility-to-protect-and-the-responsibility-while-protecting-friends-or-foes

Analysis

Democracy and Human Rights

September 15, 2012

Montenegro’s Accession To The EU: Taking Stock And Suggesting Areas For Progress

montenegros-accession-to-the-eu-taking-stock-and-suggesting-areas-for-progress

Briefing

Democracy and Human Rights

August 1, 2012

Electing Freedom? Key Challenges For Libya After The 7 July 2012 Election

electing-freedom-key-challenges-for-libya-after-the-7-july-2012-election

Briefing

Peace and Security

August 1, 2012

The Somali Crisis and the EU: Moving Onshore and Committing to Somalia

the-somali-crisis-and-the-eu-moving-onshore-and-committing-to-somalia

Analysis

Peace and Security

July 1, 2012

United Nations - European Union Cooperation in the Field of Peacekeeping: Challenges and Prospects

united-nations-european-union-cooperation-in-the-field-of-peacekeeping-challenges-and-prospects

Analysis

Peace and Security

June 1, 2012

Widening The Huntress’s Reach: Legal And Strategic Aspects Of A New Atalanta Mandate

legal-and-strategic-aspects-of-a-new-atalanta-mandate

Briefing

Democracy and Human Rights

April 15, 2012

The Biological Weapons Convention, Bioterrorism And The Life Sciences

the-biological-weapons-convention-bioterrorism-and-the-life-sciences

Briefing

Peace and Security

April 1, 2012

A Democratic Justification for Military and Non-military Humanitarian Intervention

a-democratic-justification-for-military-and-non-military-humanitarian-interventions

Analysis

Democracy and Human Rights

April 1, 2012

Climate Change and Security: Adapting the Discussion to the Evidence

climate-change-and-security

Briefing

Global Environmental Governance

March 15, 2012

The United Nations Entity for Gender Equality and the Empowerment of Women (UN Women)

the-united-nations-entity-for-gender-equality-and-the-empowerment-of-women-un-women

Backgrounder

Peace and Security

September 1, 2011

The International Criminal Court and Kenya’s Post-election Violence

the-international-criminal-court-and-kenyas-post-election-violence

Analysis

Democracy and Human Rights

July 15, 2011

The United Nations Peacebuilding Architecture: Background Note

the-united-nations-peacebuilding-architecture-background-note

Briefing

Peace and Security

March 1, 2011

European Civilian Crisis Management Capacities: Bridging The Resources Gap?

european-civilian-crisis-management-capacities-bridging-the-resources-gap

Briefing

Peace and Security

January 15, 2011

The Changing Constellation of Power and Resistance in the Global Debate over Agrofuels

the-changing-constellation-of-power-and-resistance-in-the-global-debate-over-agrofuels

Analysis

Global Environmental Governance

January 1, 2011